Turkle writes about the multiple identities that people can establish online and their real life RL identity. What Turkel does not do is go beyond mere descriptions of virtual worlds and identities that people have established. She writes about virtual worlds in a way that approves of them and regards them as wonderful creations and multiple representations of one's self. Where is the analysis of the affect of multiple virtual identities. Sure it's great that people can escape of travel into different identities and communities. Or is it?What about the inherent dangers and misguided use of virtual identities? They seem to be disruptive to the RL identity. As educators I don't think these are the identities that we are seeking to have or students establish. I think that we instead are attempting to help our students expand and enrich their RL identity. One way of keeping students identities centered or at least not imaginary is to always have students stick with one identity, their RL one, while participating in learning communities.
Reflection on Turkle reading for 2/7
Categories:
No TrackBacks
TrackBack URL: https://blogs.psu.edu/mt4/mt-tb.cgi/149092
3 Comments
Leave a comment
Search This Blog
Important Stuff
Recent Comments
Recent Entries
- Spring 2012 Syllabus
- Course Faculty This course is co-taught by friends and colleagues, Dr. Scott McDonald and Cole Camplese. This is the…
- By Cole W. Camplese | Comments (0)
- Annotation #3
- Rogers, P.C., Graham, C.R., & Mayes, C. (2007). Cultural competence and instructional design: Exploration research into the delivery of…
- By LI-CHUN WANG | Comments (0)
- Annotation #2
- Wang, Chun-Min & Reeves, (2007).Thomas. The Meaning of Culture in Online Education. Chapter 1, The Meaning of Culture in…
- By LI-CHUN WANG | Comments (0)
Semesters
Tag Cloud
- #teamtweet
- 2007
- 2008
- 2010
- 597
- 95 theses
- academic publishing
- amazon
- announcement
- Apple
- articles
- assessment
- assignment
- audible
- becci
- blog
- blogging
- blogs
- boundaries
- boyd
- brandon
- bureaucracy
- care bears
- Christmast
- Chumby
- CI 597
- ci 597
- ci597
- ci597a
- ci597c
- CI597C
- CI597C Community
- CI597C Wenger
- class
- Class Assignments
- Class Discussion
- cliche
- cloud
- cluetrain manifeso
- CMS
- comic
- Community
- community
- community informatics
- conference
- context
- copyright
- credentials
- danah
- dawes
- definition
- definitions
- Definitions
- Definitions if Community
- Design
- design
- Digg
- Digital Commons
- digital divide
- Digital Expression
- digital literacy
- discussion
- disrupti
- disruptive technology
- Disruptive Technology
- distributed cognition
- donna
- education
- Educause
- elearning
- elements of diffusion
- ELI
- ELIAnnual08
- enterprise 2.0
- ePortfolio
- ETS
- ETS Talk
- faculty
- fiancee
- final_project
- flickr
- food
- Funny
- future
- Futures
- games
- Gladwell
- globalization
- golden slipper camp
- Good Stuff
- google apps
- google earth
- group 4
- group discussion
- harvard
- havenots
- haves
- help
- identity
- Identity
- iLife
- innovation
- instant gratification
- instructions
- interesting
- Interesting Site
- internet
- introduction
- iPad
- iPhone
- itunes u
- knowledge
- learning
- links
- lists
- liz
- LMS
- lurkers
- manyeyes
- mcluhan
- meaning
- media
- mike
- mini tour
- mobility
- mott
- multi-discipline
- New England Patriots
- nmc
- non-formal learning
- norman
- notetaker
- NPR
- nyt
- NYT
- obit for d&d creator
- one button web
- online community
- open
- open education
- openness
- outlaw
- pedagogical
- pedagogy
- Personal Introduction
- philadelphia
- photos
- PLE
- pligg
- podcast
- Podcast
- Podcasts
- portfolio
- presentation
- presidential community
- privacy
- professors
- prohibit
- psu
- PSU
- PSU Blogging
- PSU Podcasting
- psuhack
- psutlt
- publishing
- questions
- RadioLab
- rant
- reading
- Reality/Surreality
- reference
- reflection
- resource
- Resources
- response
- respose
- revere
- rheingold
- rhiengold
- rogers
- RSS
- rubenstein
- schedule
- science
- scraping
- screencast
- second life
- secondlife
- self-directed learning
- skills
- slides
- social graph
- social network
- social networking sites
- society
- sources
- spring 2010
- storytelling
- syllabus
- Syllabus
- synthesis
- Teaching
- teaching
- team 1
- Team 2
- Team 3
- team 3
- team 4
- team PC
- team2
- teamtweet
- Tech Cafe
- technology
- Technology
- tenure
- THe
- The Tipping Point
- thinking
- This American Life
- thoughts
- Thoughts
- tlt
- TLT Symposium
- tltsymposium2008
- tltsymposium2010
- tools
- Travel
- trends
- tweet talk
- tweets
- tweets youtube pic
- video
- virtual community
- virtual reality
- visualization
- web
- web 2.0
- web2
- web2.0
- wenger
- Wenger
- wesch
- wikis
- Wired
- word tree
- WordPress
- WordPress Stuff
- WVU
- Youtube
- youtube
Monthly Archives
- January 2012 (1)
- April 2010 (63)
- March 2010 (40)
- February 2010 (34)
- January 2010 (79)
- November 2009 (2)
- October 2009 (1)
- June 2009 (1)
- May 2009 (3)
- April 2009 (1)
- March 2009 (1)
- December 2008 (1)
- August 2008 (8)
- July 2008 (1)
- May 2008 (32)
- April 2008 (98)
- March 2008 (70)
- February 2008 (216)
- January 2008 (131)
- December 2007 (27)
- November 2007 (14)
I agree that students' virtual identities are not the ones teachers want to be enriched first and foremost. Sure, the benefits might trickle over into their RL identities but it doesn't seem like much from experience. I'd rather not teach a bunch of kids who care little about the channels we're using with them (talking, voices, body language, etc).
I think you have just touched on the next phase of research. I wonder what research is out there (if any) on multiple personalities (the online version)?
Doesn't enriching any identity, whether virtual or real, benefit the person to which that identity belongs?
After starting this course I decided to revisit the virtual world and checkout a few chat rooms. It does not appear that much has change from when I first visited them over a decade ago. I was in a room that was titled "Talk" and there was a lot of chatting going on but nothing substantial, though there was plenty of name calling and obscenities.
However, eventually I ended up chatting with someone about teaching. I told this person about how I was frustrated last semester because of the lack of attention of many of the students. This person then asked what would I do to make learning interesting for her. It dawned on me that, for a variety of reasons, I had not done much of this for the students I had last semester and that it is not just the students who need to pay attention but that I need to make education interesting for them. I think that this includes learning to interact with students in the ways that they are accustomed.