Okay, I must confess that Wenger is starting to win me over. I have these grandiose ideas about identity; however, my vocabulary to describe such thoughts is quite lacking. Where Wenger excels (and the reason I am becoming an aficionado) is his ability to use eloquent language to explain his theories. On page 169, Wenger talks about institutionalized non-participation in that aspects of the institution or context create and/or promote non-participation of its members. Wenger uses the examples of claims processors who claim to not want to discuss job-related topics during breaks yet their conversations are saturated with such aspects. This example made me think of talk in the teacher's lounge at school. During lunch, teachers formed groups, or communities if you will. I remember that they, too, had a similar rule of outlawing talk related to school during that time, but just like claims processors, realized the fact that that which is forbidden quickly finds entrance. To me, the job of teaching provided the common experience, the focus, around which the community had a shared experience, but this potential bond was marginalized. Why do we outlaw the glue that could hold the pieces of the puzzle together permanently?Wenger also talks about the balance between the institution and its workers by saying, "You give me your time, and I'll give you money; you don't invest yourself in me, and I won't invest myself in you." This quote made me think of teacher unions and their role in institutionalized non-participation. I was often told not to extend myself too much, otherwise administration would expect that standard from me and give me nothing in return. It seems as if this institutionalized non-participation can be detrimental to both the COP within the school and to the students. How does one combat institutionalized non-participation if it is an undesired trait (to which I am inferring in this case)?
Will you, too, confess to being a Wenger aficionado?
Categories:
No TrackBacks
TrackBack URL: https://blogs.psu.edu/mt4/mt-tb.cgi/149262
2 Comments
Leave a comment
Search This Blog
Important Stuff
Recent Comments
Recent Entries
- Spring 2012 Syllabus
- Course Faculty This course is co-taught by friends and colleagues, Dr. Scott McDonald and Cole Camplese. This is the…
- By Cole W. Camplese | Comments (0)
- Annotation #3
- Rogers, P.C., Graham, C.R., & Mayes, C. (2007). Cultural competence and instructional design: Exploration research into the delivery of…
- By LI-CHUN WANG | Comments (0)
- Annotation #2
- Wang, Chun-Min & Reeves, (2007).Thomas. The Meaning of Culture in Online Education. Chapter 1, The Meaning of Culture in…
- By LI-CHUN WANG | Comments (0)
Semesters
Tag Cloud
- #teamtweet
- 2007
- 2008
- 2010
- 597
- 95 theses
- academic publishing
- amazon
- announcement
- Apple
- articles
- assessment
- assignment
- audible
- becci
- blog
- blogging
- blogs
- boundaries
- boyd
- brandon
- bureaucracy
- care bears
- Christmast
- Chumby
- CI 597
- ci 597
- ci597
- ci597a
- ci597c
- CI597C
- CI597C Community
- CI597C Wenger
- class
- Class Assignments
- Class Discussion
- cliche
- cloud
- cluetrain manifeso
- CMS
- comic
- Community
- community
- community informatics
- conference
- context
- copyright
- credentials
- danah
- dawes
- definition
- definitions
- Definitions
- Definitions if Community
- Design
- design
- Digg
- Digital Commons
- digital divide
- Digital Expression
- digital literacy
- discussion
- disrupti
- disruptive technology
- Disruptive Technology
- distributed cognition
- donna
- education
- Educause
- elearning
- elements of diffusion
- ELI
- ELIAnnual08
- enterprise 2.0
- ePortfolio
- ETS
- ETS Talk
- faculty
- fiancee
- final_project
- flickr
- food
- Funny
- future
- Futures
- games
- Gladwell
- globalization
- golden slipper camp
- Good Stuff
- google apps
- google earth
- group 4
- group discussion
- harvard
- havenots
- haves
- help
- identity
- Identity
- iLife
- innovation
- instant gratification
- instructions
- interesting
- Interesting Site
- internet
- introduction
- iPad
- iPhone
- itunes u
- knowledge
- learning
- links
- lists
- liz
- LMS
- lurkers
- manyeyes
- mcluhan
- meaning
- media
- mike
- mini tour
- mobility
- mott
- multi-discipline
- New England Patriots
- nmc
- non-formal learning
- norman
- notetaker
- NPR
- nyt
- NYT
- obit for d&d creator
- one button web
- online community
- open
- open education
- openness
- outlaw
- pedagogical
- pedagogy
- Personal Introduction
- philadelphia
- photos
- PLE
- pligg
- podcast
- Podcast
- Podcasts
- portfolio
- presentation
- presidential community
- privacy
- professors
- prohibit
- psu
- PSU
- PSU Blogging
- PSU Podcasting
- psuhack
- psutlt
- publishing
- questions
- RadioLab
- rant
- reading
- Reality/Surreality
- reference
- reflection
- resource
- Resources
- response
- respose
- revere
- rheingold
- rhiengold
- rogers
- RSS
- rubenstein
- schedule
- science
- scraping
- screencast
- second life
- secondlife
- self-directed learning
- skills
- slides
- social graph
- social network
- social networking sites
- society
- sources
- spring 2010
- storytelling
- syllabus
- Syllabus
- synthesis
- Teaching
- teaching
- team 1
- Team 2
- Team 3
- team 3
- team 4
- team PC
- team2
- teamtweet
- Tech Cafe
- technology
- Technology
- tenure
- THe
- The Tipping Point
- thinking
- This American Life
- thoughts
- Thoughts
- tlt
- TLT Symposium
- tltsymposium2008
- tltsymposium2010
- tools
- Travel
- trends
- tweet talk
- tweets
- tweets youtube pic
- video
- virtual community
- virtual reality
- visualization
- web
- web 2.0
- web2
- web2.0
- wenger
- Wenger
- wesch
- wikis
- Wired
- word tree
- WordPress
- WordPress Stuff
- WVU
- Youtube
- youtube
Monthly Archives
- January 2012 (1)
- April 2010 (63)
- March 2010 (40)
- February 2010 (34)
- January 2010 (79)
- November 2009 (2)
- October 2009 (1)
- June 2009 (1)
- May 2009 (3)
- April 2009 (1)
- March 2009 (1)
- December 2008 (1)
- August 2008 (8)
- July 2008 (1)
- May 2008 (32)
- April 2008 (98)
- March 2008 (70)
- February 2008 (216)
- January 2008 (131)
- December 2007 (27)
- November 2007 (14)
I don't have answers to your questions but I do agree with your thoughts. Like yourself I am starting to understand the reasons behind using Wenger as our course material. Wenger describes COPs and Identity in such a way that they are easily applied to education and Web 2.0. technologies. It is very interesting that teachers try not to talk about teaching during lunch but it usually weaves its way into the discussion. The same can be said about grad and Ph.D. students. I have often wondered why the grad groups I have been a part of seem to only chat about classes and common experiences (knowing there was so much more to life), yet it is all making sense now.
I agree - people often agree not to talk shop only to find themselves doing just that moments later. This has to do with being unable to completely partition our identities.