This Blog has been created and developed by

Welcome to the website for LMS Pilot Support!

In August 2009, the Provost and Vice Provost for Information Technology charged the eLearning Strategic Committee to shape the future of Penn State's learning environment. The committee, comprised of key representatives from across the colleges, campuses and Information Technology Services (ITS), was charged with developing a strategy for sustaining a common eLearning environment across the university. The four major criteria are:

  • Pedagogical: providing the tools needed for faculty and students.
  • Technology Management: system architecture, scalability, security, development, quality assurance, etc.
  • Organizational Administration: policy issues (academic, operational), data retention, user support, training, etc.
  • Cost: hardware, software, lifecycle, operations and maintenance, staff, etc.

To accomplish this charge, the eLearning Strategic Committee formed two advisory committees (pedagogical and technical) to explore the capabilities of several existing and emergent LMS products. Membership of the strategic and two advisory committees is provided at Appendix A. The LMS products explored were Blackboard, Desire2Learn (D2L), Moodle and Sakai. The advisory committees developed scorecards (criteria) and evaluated areas such as features, functionality, the user-interface, scalability, performance, security, etc., and reported their findings back to the eLearning Strategic Committee. The eLearning Strategic Committee recommended ITS pilot three LMS products: Moodle and Desire2Learn (D2L) in the fall 2010 semester and, Blackboard in spring 2011. The total number of course sections and students in the pilots are provided below. To read a complete list of the courses and faculty who have / are participating in the pilots select it from the About tab drop down menu located in the navigation bar at the top of the page.

  • Blackboard
    • 20 course sections
    • ~625 students
  • Desire2Learn
    • 14 course sections
    • ~330 students
  • Moodle
    • 11 course sections
    • ~475 students

The assessment strategy for the three products piloted included the methodological triangulation approach of collecting data through surveys, direct observations, and focus groups.

  • Surveys were conducted several times over the course of the pilot with the goal of collecting a cross-sectional body of the participant's experience.
  • Direct observations of faculty and instructional designers as they built their course were done to gain a deeper understanding of the course construction process.
  • Faculty and student focus groups were held to assess the strengths and weaknesses of each platform in a group setting.

The review of the data collected during the fall and spring pilots indicated no preference when it came to the core functionalities of each product. Based on the analysis of all three platforms, the eLearning Strategic Committee has concluded that a request for purchase (RFP) should be completed by all vendors (Moodlerooms, Desire2Learn, and Blackboard). This approach will allow the university the opportunity to further evaluate each product as far as its future direction, infrastructure, hosting, and cost of ownership as well as our potential business relationship with each company.

More information about LMS Pilot

Recent Entries

Course Notification Available for Blackboard
Course Notifications can now be sent to individuals' email and mobile devices using the Mobile Learn application. By default…
Important Notice: 1st Blackboard Webinar, Thursday, 2/10, 2:00-3:00 PM
Justin Beck of Blackboard will be hosting the first Blackboard question and answer session this Thursday, 2/10. The session will…
Blackboard Mobile Learn Available
Blackboard Mobile Learn is now available as part of the LMS pilot. Blackboard Mobile Learn is an app available for…